Ask a lawyer:
Is it legal for a president to fire the entire cabinet?

mwakili.com

Introduction

In Kenya, the President holds significant executive powers, including the authority to appoint and dismiss members of the Cabinet. This power is enshrined in the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, and is subject to certain legal and procedural requirements. The recent dismissal of the entire Cabinet by President William Ruto has raised questions about the legality and implications of such actions. This article will explore the legal framework governing the President's authority to fire the Cabinet, the constitutional provisions, and the potential consequences of such decisions.

Constitutional Provisions
Presidential Powers and Limitations
Historical Context and Precedents
Legal and Political Implications
Conclusion

1. Constitutional Provisions

The Constitution of Kenya, 2010, provides a clear framework for the appointment and dismissal of Cabinet Secretaries. Article 152 of the Constitution outlines the composition and functions of the Cabinet, as well as the President's authority in this regard.

1.1 Appointment of Cabinet Secretaries

According to Article 152(2):

"The President shall nominate and, with the approval of the National Assembly, appoint Cabinet Secretaries."

This provision ensures that the appointment of Cabinet Secretaries is not solely at the discretion of the President but requires the approval of the National Assembly.

1.2 Dismissal of Cabinet Secretaries

Article 152(5) states:

"The President may re-assign a Cabinet Secretary, or dismiss a Cabinet Secretary."

This clause grants the President the authority to dismiss any Cabinet Secretary. However, it does not explicitly address the dismissal of the entire Cabinet at once.

(Source: Kenya Law Reform Commission ↗)

2. Presidential Powers and Limitations

The President's power to dismiss Cabinet Secretaries is part of the broader executive authority vested in the office. However, this power is not absolute and is subject to constitutional and legal constraints.

2.1 Executive Authority

Article 132 of the Constitution outlines the functions of the President, including the power to:

"Direct and coordinate the functions of ministries and government departments."

This provision underscores the President's role in ensuring the effective functioning of the executive branch, which may include the dismissal of underperforming or controversial Cabinet Secretaries.

2.2 Checks and Balances

While the President has the authority to dismiss Cabinet Secretaries, this power is balanced by the requirement for parliamentary approval for appointments. This system of checks and balances is designed to prevent the abuse of executive power and ensure accountability.

(Source: The Constitution of Kenya, 2010 ↗)

3. Historical Context and Precedents

The recent dismissal of the entire Cabinet by President William Ruto is unprecedented in Kenya's history. Previous presidents have exercised their authority to dismiss individual Cabinet Secretaries, but the wholesale dismissal of the Cabinet is a significant and rare event.

3.1 Previous Dismissals

Historically, Kenyan presidents have dismissed individual Cabinet Secretaries for various reasons, including corruption, incompetence, and political disagreements. These dismissals have often been controversial and have sometimes led to legal challenges and political instability.

3.2 Current Context

The recent dismissal of the entire Cabinet by President Ruto follows weeks of protests and political unrest. The decision appears to be a response to public pressure and a move to reassert control over the executive branch. The legality of this action, while supported by the constitutional provisions, may still be subject to political and legal scrutiny.

(Source: BBC ↗, Washington Post ↗)

4. Legal and Political Implications

The dismissal of the entire Cabinet has significant legal and political implications for Kenya. These implications include potential challenges to the President's authority, the impact on governance, and the response from the National Assembly and the public.

4.1 Legal Challenges

While the Constitution grants the President the authority to dismiss Cabinet Secretaries, the wholesale dismissal of the Cabinet may be challenged on legal grounds. Opponents may argue that such a move undermines the principles of collective responsibility and continuity in governance.

4.2 Impact on Governance

The dismissal of the entire Cabinet can lead to a period of uncertainty and disruption in government operations. The process of appointing and obtaining parliamentary approval for new Cabinet Secretaries may take time, during which critical government functions could be affected.

4.3 Political Response

The political response to the dismissal of the Cabinet will be crucial in determining the stability of the government. The National Assembly, opposition parties, and the public may react strongly to the President's decision, potentially leading to further protests and political instability.

(Source: France24 ↗, VOA News ↗)

Conclusion

In conclusion, the President of Kenya has the constitutional authority to dismiss Cabinet Secretaries, including the entire Cabinet. This power is part of the broader executive authority vested in the office of the President. However, the exercise of this power is subject to legal and political constraints, including the requirement for parliamentary approval for new appointments and the potential for legal challenges. The recent dismissal of the entire Cabinet by President William Ruto is a significant and unprecedented event that will have far-reaching implications for Kenya's governance and political stability.

Sources