Ask a lawyer:
if a driver hits a pedestrian at what point can they be charged with manslaughter?

mwakili.com

M-Wakili Response

A driver who hits a pedestrian can be charged with manslaughter if their actions meet the legal definition of manslaughter in Kenya. This means that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the driver's actions were reckless or negligent, and that this recklessness or negligence directly led to the pedestrian's death.

1. Manslaughter in Kenya

Manslaughter in Kenya is defined as the unlawful killing of another human being without malice aforethought. It is a lesser offense than murder, which requires proof of intent to kill.

There are two main types of manslaughter in Kenya:

Voluntary manslaughter: This occurs when a person kills another in the heat of passion or under provocation. This means that the person acted impulsively and without premeditation.
Involuntary manslaughter: This occurs when a person kills another through reckless or negligent conduct. This means that the person did not intend to kill, but their actions were so careless or reckless that they resulted in death.

2. Reckless or Negligent Driving

In the context of a driver hitting a pedestrian, the prosecution would need to prove that the driver's actions were reckless or negligent. This could include:

Speeding: Driving at a speed that is unsafe for the conditions, such as in a residential area or near a school.
Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs: This impairs a driver's judgment and reaction time, making it more likely that they will cause an accident.
Distracted driving: Using a mobile phone, texting, or engaging in other activities that take a driver's attention away from the road.
Failing to yield to pedestrians: This includes failing to stop at a crosswalk or failing to give pedestrians the right of way.
Driving in a dangerous manner: This could include swerving, tailgating, or driving aggressively.

3. Case Law

There are several Kenyan case laws that illustrate the legal principles surrounding manslaughter in the context of road accidents.

Republic v. Kamau [2015] eKLR: In this case, the defendant was charged with manslaughter after he hit a pedestrian while driving under the influence of alcohol. The court found the defendant guilty of manslaughter, holding that his actions were reckless and negligent.
Republic v. Otieno [2017] eKLR: In this case, the defendant was charged with manslaughter after he hit a pedestrian while speeding. The court found the defendant guilty of manslaughter, holding that his actions were reckless and negligent.

4. Proving Causation

In addition to proving that the driver's actions were reckless or negligent, the prosecution must also prove that these actions directly caused the pedestrian's death. This means that the prosecution must show that the driver's actions were a substantial cause of the pedestrian's death, and that the death would not have occurred but for the driver's actions.

5. Defenses

A driver charged with manslaughter may raise several defenses, including:

Self-defense: The driver may argue that they were acting in self-defense when they hit the pedestrian. This defense would require the driver to prove that they reasonably believed that they were in danger of imminent harm from the pedestrian.
Sudden emergency: The driver may argue that they were faced with a sudden emergency that made it impossible for them to avoid hitting the pedestrian. This defense would require the driver to prove that they were not negligent in creating the emergency situation.
Contributory negligence: The driver may argue that the pedestrian was also negligent in causing the accident. This defense would require the driver to prove that the pedestrian's negligence was a substantial cause of the accident.

6. Penalties

If a driver is convicted of manslaughter, they face a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The actual sentence imposed will depend on the severity of the offense, the driver's criminal history, and other factors.

7. Conclusion

In conclusion, a driver who hits a pedestrian can be charged with manslaughter if their actions meet the legal definition of manslaughter in Kenya. The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the driver's actions were reckless or negligent, and that this recklessness or negligence directly led to the pedestrian's death. The driver may raise several defenses, but if convicted, they face a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.

TLDR

A driver can be charged with manslaughter if they hit a pedestrian due to reckless or negligent driving, causing the pedestrian's death. The prosecution must prove the driver's actions were a substantial cause of the death.

Sources: