Ask a lawyer:
can Macharia Gaitho sue the government for what they did?
Can Macharia Gaitho Sue the Government for His Arrest?
Table of Contents
Introduction
Legal Grounds for Suing the Government
Relevant Case Laws
Conclusion
Sources
1. Introduction
Macharia Gaitho, a veteran journalist, was recently arrested by the police in what has been described as a case of mistaken identity. This incident has raised questions about his legal rights and whether he can sue the government for the ordeal he experienced. In Kenya, the legal framework provides avenues for individuals to seek redress against the government for wrongful actions, including unlawful arrests.
2. Legal Grounds for Suing the Government
2.1 Constitutional Rights
The Constitution of Kenya, 2010, provides robust protections for individual rights. Article 29 guarantees the right to freedom and security of the person, which includes the right not to be subjected to arbitrary arrest or detention. If Macharia Gaitho's arrest was indeed arbitrary, it would constitute a violation of this constitutional right.
2.2 The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights Act
The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights Act, 2011, establishes the Kenya National Commission on Human Rights (KNCHR), which is mandated to investigate human rights violations. Macharia Gaitho can lodge a complaint with the KNCHR, which can then investigate the matter and recommend appropriate action.
2.3 The National Police Service Act
The National Police Service Act, 2011, outlines the conduct expected of police officers. Section 95 of the Act provides for the accountability of police officers and allows for complaints to be made against them for misconduct. If the police officers involved in Macharia Gaitho's arrest acted outside the scope of their lawful duties, they could be held accountable under this Act.
2.4 The Tort of False Imprisonment
False imprisonment is a common law tort that occurs when a person is unlawfully restrained against their will. In the case of Macharia Gaitho, if it can be proven that his arrest was unlawful and without just cause, he could sue the government for false imprisonment. This would require demonstrating that the police officers had no legal justification for detaining him.
3. Relevant Case Laws
3.1 Githunguri v. Republic [1986] KLR 1
In this case, the High Court of Kenya held that the arrest and detention of the applicant were unlawful and ordered his immediate release. The court emphasized the importance of adhering to constitutional safeguards against arbitrary arrest and detention.
3.2 Koigi Wamwere v. Attorney General [2004] eKLR
Koigi Wamwere, a political activist, successfully sued the government for unlawful detention and torture. The court awarded him damages, underscoring the principle that the government can be held liable for the actions of its agents that violate constitutional rights.
3.3 Gitobu Imanyara & 2 others v. Attorney General [2016] eKLR
In this case, the Court of Appeal awarded damages to the petitioners for unlawful detention and violation of their constitutional rights. The court reiterated that the state is responsible for ensuring that its agents do not infringe on the rights of individuals.
4. Conclusion
Macharia Gaitho has several legal avenues to seek redress for his arrest. He can file a constitutional petition alleging violation of his rights under the Constitution of Kenya, 2010. Additionally, he can lodge a complaint with the Kenya National Commission on Human Rights or pursue a civil suit for false imprisonment. The relevant case laws indicate that the Kenyan judiciary has a history of holding the government accountable for unlawful actions by its agents.
5. Sources
By leveraging these legal provisions and precedents, Macharia Gaitho can seek justice and hold the government accountable for any violations of his rights.
Answered by mwakili.com